Saturday, March 17, 2007

Dialogue AA

"Where'd you pick up your love of football?"

Now she smiled, grateful that he'd changed the subject, even a little. "That was all Aunt Tab. Her husband was a faithful Chiefs fan even back when they were in Texas [the Dallas Texans]. His loyalty followed them to Kansas City. Lasted 'til the day he died." Her smile deepened. "Aunt Tab kept up the tradition and it just kinda got passed down to us. I wish I could have met him. I think we would have been like peas and carrots. She always said I carried a bit of his ghost because we were entirely too much alike."

"How long were you with her? Must have been a long time to breed such loyalty to a team that hasn't been to the Super Bowl since--"

"Hey!" She laughed, lobbing a slice of bread at him. "A team is more than its win-loss column, you know."

"As anyone with such a shoddy win record will attest." [My research shows the Chiefs with an all-time record of 383 wins, 334 losses. Not so shoddy.]

"Jerk." Shaking her head, she shot him an assessing look. "And just who holds your loyalty, oh god of the gridiron?"

"You don't want to know."

"Oh, no. If you're a Raiders fan, you can leave right now."

--Gutterball

I assumed the "they" in sentence 4 referred to the team, but most readers would have thought you meant Tab and her husband.

It was fine to begin with, but when someone's droning on about a football team, you probably want to get in and get out and get on to something more interesting to the readers. Like a murder.

7 comments:

pacatrue said...

I just wanted to say that I read the very first sentence and thought, "This is Gutterball's."

GutterBall said...

Damn, Pac-Man. Am I that obvious?

And don't worry. The conversation goes downhill fast. She was trying desperately to avoid the other conversation, but he goes right back to it after this.

Heh, and the "win record" comment was more about their Super Bowl record. I can easily clarify that. My boys (and hers) really have been a winning-ish team in the regular season.

whitemouse said...

I liked the way the characters spoke - that struck me as realistic - and I liked the banter between them. There was a nice, light-hearted tension there that kept me engaged.

However, football's not going to keep me engaged for very long. As EE suggested, this scene should probably be kept short and should move on to something more critical to the plot soon. (Bodies! Where are the dead bodies?! *slobber, slobber, drooool*)

McKoala said...

LOL the Raiders line. EE's cuts sharpen this up a lot.

LOL Whitemouse. Pull that tongue in.

bunnygirl said...

Gutterball, I'm glad you say this is about it for the football talk. Otherwise I'd be having to say I hope this is a football novel of some sort.

Other than throwing the piece of bread (how old is the woman speaking?), this could work as an attempt to change the topic. Just so long as we quickly go back to our regularly scheduled murder and mayhem. Or title the novel "Gods of the Gridiron" or somesuch. ;-)

Anonymous said...

She lobbed a slice of bread at him?

I would hang in there for more of this scene if the rest was truly witty or veered into serious conflict. Otherwise, it sounds like a competent if standard-issue "get to know you" romantic scene, which just isn't my cup of tea, no matter how well done.

--Detri (dialogue J)

Wonderwood said...

I thought this was pretty good GB, but I agree about lobbing the slice of bread, I think you're better off without it. Nice job!