Saturday, March 17, 2007

Dialogue CC

Setup: Laying back, watching through the cover of the branches at the people moving far below us in the parkland at the bottom of the cliff, I asked my father what it meant to be Scotch-Irish. I hoped it was good to be that, and I hoped that he didn’t mind, as he hadn’t been included in the Scotch-Irish head count earlier in the day by an elderly relative.

“Honey, this is a dry county. That means all those people sitting there below us are pretty dry, too,” he said, with a certain look in his eye, a little bit of an eye smirk as he explained this to me.

“You know that beady-eyed cow, your grandma’s mother?” I nodded, fascinated with his frankness but unsure about what this had to do with anything.

"The stupid … " He waited just a minute. “Look. She won’t even eat rum cake.” He grinned, looking down at the family from our perch above them, so I grinned, too. I had no idea what he was talking about, but my father wasn’t the kind of person to question. You had to be careful.

“Is that bad?”

“What’s bad is not knowing how to have a good time. But the cow’s husband liked to give it a try sometimes.” He told me a story about something that happened before I was born - my dad driving [how he drove] my great-grandfather on a grand adventure to the next county to pick up a six-pack of beer that they drank all the way back to town. That my great-grandmother had lost her sense of smell so they knew she couldn’t smell the beer on their breath. B [, b]ut she had found them out [anyway]. “You’d have thought the goddamned devil was gonna shoot up from the gravel in their driveway and claim his beer-soaked soul. Jesus!

“No way I’d put up with that. No way,” my father said.

I believed him. But to this very day, I still don't know what it means to be Scotch-Irish.

--Anonymous

Nice. Good job of creating a memorable character through dialogue.

Early on it was "all those people" down below. Later it was "the family." Is it their family? A family reunion? Just random people in a park?

10 comments:

whitemouse said...

I agree that the father's character is well established by this. Nice work!

Some of the phrasing seemed a bit off to me (such as He waited just a minute instead of He paused.). However, it wasn't so strange that it pulled me out of the story.

I got a little confused by the placement of the paragraph breaks. I'd rather see actions and words for one character all in one paragraph, and the actions and words of another character placed in a separate paragraph. For example, this strikes me as less confusing:

"The stupid … " He waited just a minute. “Look. She won’t even eat rum cake.” He grinned, looking down at the family from our perch above them.

I grinned, too. I had no idea what he was talking about, but my father wasn’t the kind of person to question. You had to be careful. “Is that bad?”

Anonymous said...

Thanks, EE. It wasn't clear from this portion of the dialogue that the father doesn't feel related to the people below, as they are his in-laws, and he doesn't like them, and the feeling is mutual. This makes any family ties ambiguous at best.

And thanks also for your comments, whitemouse. I can see what you mean about the paragraphs.

Anonymous said...

Only one niggle here: Scotch is a drink. Scottish is a nationality...

Anonymous said...

The Protestant Irish who immigrated to the United Sates began referring to themselves as Scotch-Irish after the Catholic Irish began immigrating to the U.S. in increasing numbers in the 1800s. They felt a need to distinguish themselves from the Catholics - as the Catholic Irish were looked down upon, as many new immigrant groups are looked down upon, as "less than equals", until the newness wears off, and time passes. Those referring to themselves as Scotch-Irish may have long ago called themselves Scots-Irish, but, eventually, most people of this background, in many parts of the country, began to call themselves Scotch-Irish.

Dave said...

Interesting story about a grand adventure for a six pack!

I'm missing the rest of the story. That's not a criticism. I have the feeling that something turns on the fact that a character is Scotch-Irish or that this conversation is pivotal. But that is more than we can read here.

Anonymous said...

You're right, Dave, and thanks for noticing this.

takoda said...

I loved "eye smirk!" Very clever choice of words!

McKoala said...

It's true, though, that in Scotland, Scotch is almost exclusively used for whisky. (The exceptions are pretty much traditional products aka 'names of things')

Anonymous said...

Leave it to the Irish to wax lyrical over a simple question. :) I'd read on.

--Detri (dialogue J)

Anonymous said...

Thanks, takoda.

Good one, Detri - yeah, you're right - most of us don't need the Blarney stone to get a good one going.

Robin